My next review is of Domination by Alice Roberts, subtitled “The Fall of the Roman Empire and the Rise of Christianity”.
The book is divided into five parts (Land of Saints, The End of Empire, The Heart of Empire, The Business of Empire and Ruler of All) each divided into around ten sections apart from the final part which is a summary and rather shorter.
I must admit to having been a bit cautious about buying this book since Professor Alice Roberts is a relatively high profile humanist so perhaps not sympathetic to the Christian church. On reflection I realised that this was probably an ideal person to write a history of the rise of the Christian church.
Roberts is generally known for writing on anatomy and archaeology. This book is much more historical in character, relying more on written records than archaeology. As a result I think she spends more time being explicit about how we read historical records than might otherwise be the case.
Domination starts in Llantwit Major, in South Wales, with the 6th century saint, Illtud. In a way this is starting at the end, the Roman Empire has fallen but in its place we find a Christian church that in this case is spanning South Wales, Devon and Cornwall and crossing into Brittany. These links were close, Welsh Cornish and Breton were mutually intelligible up until the 11th century there are even provinces in Brittany whose names are similar to Devon and Cornwall.
Roberts writes here about the reliability of written sources from this time. In the early church there was a proliferation of saints, the Pope had no part in sanctifying them until the 12th century. Often saints were promoted in later years with “Live of [your saint here] ” documents, written by members of the church some time later (possibly centuries) with a view to promoting the interests of those places and churches attached to the saint – as such they can’t be considered literal truth. This isn’t to say meaning can’t be extracted from them, we can favour documents written closer to contemporaneously, we can cross-reference between “lives of”, and we can pay attention to what themes emerge and what was seen as desirable in a saint.
Roberts next covers the lead up to the post-Roman period, the transition from a Roman Empire with Christianity as its official religion in 380AD to what came after. The focus here is on buildings although much of the section revolves around the letters of Sidonius Apollinaris, a senior Roman administrator and then bishop who lived from c. 430AD-490AD. Apollinaris lived in what is now France where the Empire ended around 480AD with the invasion of the Franks. Roberts comments that there is more written evidence from this period originating in Gaul than from Britain where there is virtually nothing.
Apollinaris’s letters show how the villa culture of the Roman Empire was active until very late in the Empire. Roberts suggests that Roman villas in Britain did not immediately fall into dis-repair when the Romans formally left: we see the archaeological remains of those villas out in the countryside which fell into ruin but those that went on to become villages are less obvious – the originally buildings having disappeared over the intervening 1500 years. Villas were often places of burial which became cemeteries which became churches. The Roman basicila, a large, aisled administrative building morphed very naturally into early Christian churches.
Christianity rose to dominance in the Roman Empire during the 4th century, becoming the official religion in 380 AD with the Edict of Thessalonica by Theodosius I. Roberts talks much more about Constantine who instituted the Council of Nicaea in 325AD to decide on the fundamentals of what was faith and what was heresy. She talks about this as an exercise in branding and marketing, and a type of culture war. Culture war is a recurring theme through the book, mainly in terms of defining what faith meant in the Christian Church. Constantine was looking for unity in the church to align with his leadership of a newly unified Roman Empire. Constantine had recently got rid of the other members of the tetrarchy ruling the Roman Empire. Later ecclesiastical historians would pitch Constantine as instrumental in making the Christian church the official religion of the Empire through his faith.
Roberts focus then moves to the people that made up the Christian church in the Roman Empire and how its functions grew. Middle-class professionals were moving to the Christian church because it represented a degree of stability in an increasingly uncertain world. We saw earlier how Apollinaris, a senior Roman administrator, became a bishop – this was not an uncommon journey. Many of the early saints were from the Roman elite. Over the years the Christian church became a vast conglomerate of welfare, health, legal, agribusiness, shipping and education with a thin veil of religion cast over it, built with the assistance of the Roman state.
The final section, Ruler of all, is rather shorter and acts as a summary although in addition Roberts draws parallels in this section between the imperial purple and gold of the Roman Emperors and the vestments of bishops. Also in this section is a discussion of how Christianity came to dominate: other cults in the Roman Empire were more permissive of worshipping multiple gods – Christianity was not.
I enjoyed this book, it answers natural questions about the fall of the Roman Empire and the rise of Christianity, it’s readable and provides some good insight into historical methodology. I was interested to understand how this book was received, some brief Googling suggests that the main criticism is that it is “too cynical” – rather than attacking its scholarship.




