Tag: History

Book review: Domination by Alice Roberts

My next review is of Domination by Alice Roberts, subtitled “The Fall of the Roman Empire and the Rise of Christianity”.

The book is divided into five parts (Land of Saints, The End of Empire, The Heart of Empire, The Business of Empire and Ruler of All) each divided into around ten sections apart from the final part which is a summary and rather shorter.

I must admit to having been a bit cautious about buying this book since Professor Alice Roberts is a relatively high profile humanist so perhaps not sympathetic to the Christian church. On reflection I realised that this was probably an ideal person to write a history of the rise of the Christian church.

Roberts is generally known for writing on anatomy and archaeology. This book is much more historical in character, relying more on written records than archaeology. As a result I think she spends more time being explicit about how we read historical records than might otherwise be the case.

Domination starts in Llantwit Major, in South Wales, with the 6th century saint, Illtud. In a way this is starting at the end, the Roman Empire has fallen but in its place we find a Christian church that in this case is spanning South Wales, Devon and Cornwall and crossing into Brittany. These links were close, Welsh Cornish and Breton were mutually intelligible up until the 11th century there are even provinces in Brittany whose names are similar to Devon and Cornwall.

Roberts writes here about the reliability of written sources from this time. In the early church there was a proliferation of saints, the Pope had no part in sanctifying them until the 12th century. Often saints were promoted in later years with “Live of [your saint here] ” documents, written by members of the church some time later (possibly centuries) with a view to promoting the interests of those places and churches attached to the saint – as such they can’t be considered literal truth. This isn’t to say meaning can’t be extracted from them, we can favour documents written closer to contemporaneously, we can cross-reference between “lives of”, and we can pay attention to what themes emerge and what was seen as desirable in a saint.

Roberts next covers the lead up to the post-Roman period, the transition from a Roman Empire with Christianity as its official religion in 380AD to what came after. The focus here is on buildings although much of the section revolves around the letters of Sidonius Apollinaris, a senior Roman administrator and then bishop who lived from c. 430AD-490AD. Apollinaris lived in what is now France where the Empire ended around 480AD with the invasion of the Franks. Roberts comments that there is more written evidence from this period originating in Gaul than from Britain where there is virtually nothing.

Apollinaris’s letters show how the villa culture of the Roman Empire was active until very late in the Empire. Roberts suggests that Roman villas in Britain did not immediately fall into dis-repair when the Romans formally left: we see the archaeological remains of those villas out in the countryside which fell into ruin but those that went on to become villages are less obvious – the originally buildings having disappeared over the intervening 1500 years. Villas were often places of burial which became cemeteries which became churches. The Roman basicila, a large, aisled administrative building morphed very naturally into early Christian churches.

Christianity rose to dominance in the Roman Empire during the 4th century, becoming the official religion in 380 AD with the Edict of Thessalonica by Theodosius I. Roberts talks much more about Constantine who instituted the Council of Nicaea in 325AD to decide on the fundamentals of what was faith and what was heresy. She talks about this as an exercise in branding and marketing, and a type of culture war. Culture war is a recurring theme through the book, mainly in terms of defining what faith meant in the Christian Church. Constantine was looking for unity in the church to align with his leadership of a newly unified Roman Empire. Constantine had recently got rid of the other members of the tetrarchy ruling the Roman Empire. Later ecclesiastical historians would pitch Constantine as instrumental in making the Christian church the official religion of the Empire through his faith.

Roberts focus then moves to the people that made up the Christian church in the Roman Empire and how its functions grew. Middle-class professionals were moving to the Christian church because it represented a degree of stability in an increasingly uncertain world. We saw earlier how Apollinaris, a senior Roman administrator, became a bishop – this was not an uncommon journey. Many of the early saints were from the Roman elite. Over the years the Christian church became a vast conglomerate of welfare, health, legal, agribusiness, shipping and education with a thin veil of religion cast over it, built with the assistance of the Roman state.

The final section, Ruler of all, is rather shorter and acts as a summary although in addition Roberts draws parallels in this section between the imperial purple and gold of the Roman Emperors and the vestments of bishops. Also in this section is a discussion of how Christianity came to dominate: other cults in the Roman Empire were more permissive of worshipping multiple gods – Christianity was not.

I enjoyed this book, it answers natural questions about the fall of the Roman Empire and the rise of Christianity, it’s readable and provides some good insight into historical methodology. I was interested to understand how this book was received, some brief Googling suggests that the main criticism is that it is “too cynical” – rather than attacking its scholarship.

Book review: Hadrian’s Wall by David J. Breeze and Brian Dobson

This review is of Hadrian’s Wall by David J. Breeze and Brian Dobson. Reading this book was prompted by visiting Birdoswald Roman Fort, on Hadrian’s Wall, during a recent holiday to the Lake District. I have also read more widely about the Romans in Britain.

Hadrian’s Wall is divided into seven chapters titled The Concept of a Frontier, The Building of Hadrian’s Wall, The Antonine Wall, The Two Walls, The Army of the Wall, Life on the wall and The Third and Four Centuries.

There is a short conclusion chapter and extensive appendices covering Roman Emperors and Governors of Britain, The regiments of Hadrian’s Wall, The Gods Worshipped on the Wall, The Roman Names of the Forts on Hadrians Wall and The Evidence on the Ground.

Emperor Hadrian’s plan to build a wall at a boundary was a novelty in the Roman Empire, to that point the Roman army had acted on the implicit assumption that the boundary was the end of the land. They fought battles with mobile units with forts to provide over-winter accommodation for the following year’s fighting. Hadrian made boundaries in both Britain and Germany. They were not strictly fortification, they served to control access in and out of Roman control rather than anticipating pitched battles on the line of the wall.

Perhaps disappointingly for the British, the Roman Emperors tended to stage military actions for their own advancement, Britain sometimes provided a useful arena but more often Roman Emperors were looking to the Middle East. The Emperor Hadrian (117-138AD) had pulled back troops from Britain to fight elsewhere and planned the Wall to define the Roman area of interest in Britain.

Construction of the Wall proper started around 122AD. It was built over a relatively short period, perhaps 3 or 4 years. The Wall followed on from the older Stanegate Roman road which followed roughly the same line but a little further south. The wall itself is relatively wide, 3 metres, certainly wide enough for patrolling but not for fighting. It was built to a clear masterplan with regularly spaced milecastles (small forts), turrets and gates. A series of larger forts were added to the Wall include Birdosvald, Chesters and Vindolanda. The system of forts extends beyond the wall at the Cumbria end, down to Maryport and the is some evidence for a few forts on the North Sea coast. Breeze and Dobson include much minutiae of the construction of the wall and forts, trying to identify which parts were built by which of the several military units. The plan changed during the construction of the wall with the width reducing part way through. A “vallum”, a bank and ditch earthwork, was added south of the Wall a few years after initial construction in around 130AD.

Work on Hadrian’s wall stopped immediately on the death of Hadrian in 138AD, he was succeeded by Antonius Pius, his adopted son, who started work on his own Wall, the Antonine Wall. Although there is no evidence it seems likely that the construction was a question of military prestige, most likely backed by local generals bored of simply manning a wall. The Antonine Wall was of turf on a stone base, similarly forts had turf ramparts although might contain, it runs between the Forth and Clyde estuaries and is approximately half the length of Hadrian’s Wall. Hadrian’s Wall was largely abandoned when the Antonine Wall was built.

There’s very little written evidence for what was going on in Britain in the mid to late 2nd century. Hadrian’s Wall was reoccupied in 158AD and the Antonine Wall abandoned by the mid 160s. It seems there was some sort of uprising in southern Scotland in the last two decades of the second century.

There is quite a lot known of the structure and career paths in the Roman army, along with the standards for building forts. In the early years these don’t seem to have been greatly adapted for Northern Britain – they contain verandas to protect from the sun! Most notably Hadrian’s Wall was largely manned by auxiliary units largely drawn from the local population. Members of these units signed up for 25 years of service, with 60% surviving the full term. Auxiliary unit members were rewarded with citizenship at the end of their term. Breeze and Dobson note that promotion was often down to personal recommendations and client/patron relationships. We also know a fair amount about life on the Wall from archaeology, including the famous Vindalonda written tablets. Auxiliary soldiers may well have had wives and children who lived outside the walls of the fort or perhaps even inside in the later period of the Roman occupation.

The early third century was tumultuous for the Roman Empire in the early third century although Britain was largely outside of this, over the years. Later in the century there was fighting with the Picts. The Romans finally left Britain in 411AD, or at least that’s when they stopped paying their soldiers in Britain. It is likely individuals remained in place in the area around the wall after this date. Their departure was due problems closer to home in Rome, rather than being militarily pushed out.

It is difficult to recommend this book to the general reader. It seems more directed to the professional by including a lot of very detailed information on, for example, the proportions of forts whilst scarcely touching, for example, on where troop disposition information comes from. There are no scene building asides referencing the researchers the authors have met which is perhaps unsurprising since that was not the style for books like this when it was initially published in 1974, this edition is from 1999.

Book review: Symbols and Allegories in Art by Matilde Battistini

My next review is of Symbols and Allegories in Art by Matilde Battistini which I discovered is part of a series: Guide to Imagery which looks interesting. I found this book by searching because I was interested in understanding more about allegories in art. I knew from watching various TV programmes that there was more to paintings than their surface appearance.

Symbols is divided into an introduction, and four sections on Time, Man, Space and Allegories, each of which describe twenty or so items. Each entry describes the linguistic and mythological origins of a term and is illustrated with at least one painting or sculpture with parts of the artwork labelled. Sometimes subsequent pages show more related artworks with labels.

Most of the paintings are from the Medieval and Renaissance periods but there are some artworks from the 19th and even 20th century. I think they are all from Western Europe presumably the allegorical language elsewhere is different.

Allegorical content in artworks evolved over time, in the Medieval period it was very much about good and evil, focussed around the Christian faith. Much of the iconography of early Christian art was based on earlier mythology. During the Renaissance there was a greater direct focus on Classical themes and mythology. Later the use of allegories was codified into documents – it was a pity not to see references to an example of this. Within Christian iconography there is an evolution from the Medieval period.

I think this book is intended for the somewhat expert in art history, it doesn’t talk about why allegories appeared in paintings and who made art for whom.

In many cases the paintings helpfully contain the word “allegory” in the title, so the reading is not as blind as you might think.

Since there are a limited number of sections each section is quite broad, so the section on time includes seasons, months, times of the day, ages of man and the world and items representing the flow and circle of time.

The Seasons appear early in the book and are a good illustration of how sets of things are represented allegorically. The seasons are associated with different phases of human life birth (spring), maturity (summer), decline (autumn) and death (winter). They are also associated with animals (ram, lion, bull and snake) and gods (Zeus, Helios, Dionysus, and Hades) in Greek mythology. Seasons can also be represented by women, we can identify which season by their headwear – Spring is represented by a woman with a crown of flowers, Summer with a crown of wheat stalks. More widely figures are recognised by the objects they hold or are close to, Saturn for example is shown as an older man carrying a scythe or hourglass.

The section on man contains entries on key biblical figures like Christ, the Virgin Mary, Eve, the Trinity, angels and Satan. As well as a range of monsters of different types. There are also what seem like miscellaneous entries on eggs and mirrors. The idea of the Trinity was created in 325AD at the Council of Nicea; angels only gained wings in art in the 4th century AD and that the iconography of the Virgin Mary derives from earlier gods such as Artemis and Isis. I was interested to learn that haloes come from Indo-Iranian deities via Roman and Byzantine emperors before reaching Christianity.

One of the pictures for the Monsters entry is Piero di Cosimo’s, Perseus Frees Andromeda which features members of the Medici family – a hidden meaning not otherwise covered in the book.

The section on space covers the astronomical (sun, sky, cosmos, moon), the earthly (garden, mountain, forest, tree) and the religious (Heaven, Hell, Purgatory, Limbo). Dante’s Divine Comedy, completed in 1321, is cited a few times as a source for depictions of Hell, Purgatory and Limbo. The representations of Hell stabilised in this period.

The final section on “Allegories” is a bit different from the others, it covers items like The Senses, The Virtues, The Vices but there are rather fewer items than in the earlier sections but each is illustrated by more examples. Love is included in this section where we learn the parrot is a symbol of lust! Young women represent the cardinal virtues: fortitude, prudence, justice and temperance and the theological virtues: faith, hope and charity. The cardinal virtues derive from ancient Greek philosophy whilst the theological ones are medieval.

I must admit this book got me thinking about data. Is there a global database of paintings? How often does “allegory” appear in the title? And the somewhat off-topic question of what fraction of the paintings made in any particular period / place survive?

I found this book interesting and readable although I was expecting more on the framework into which allegorical depictions lay. The parent series definitely seems worth a look.

Book review: A History of Railways in 100 Maps by Jeremy Black

Bookshops are dangerous places, I visited one and came away with A History of Railways in 100 Maps by Jeremy Black! It is a book my dad would have loved.

A History of Railways is approximately A4 format, as well as an introduction it contains eight chapters. The first six of these are chronological and named: Origins, Spreading the New Age (1860-85), Geopolitics and War (1885-1918), Alongside Road (1919-39), War and Air Challenge (1939-70), and Rail Developments (1970-present). It finishes with chapters on “Facing the Future” and “Rail and the Collective Imagination”. Each chapter contains a series of maps, typically they are shown with a facing page of text, occasionally there are two maps associated with a piece of text.

The style of presentation, as a hundred individual maps, makes it a little difficult to pull together themes, although the chapter introductions help with this. Britain features repeatedly but the coverage is global, and Britain’s representation is just a result of the early start made on railways in the country.

The format of maps evolved over the years, as technology improved. Surveying, mapping and printing had developed through the 18th century, prior to the railways, in part to support the creation of turnpike roads and then canals as well as prospecting for minerals for the developing Industrial Revolution. A recurring theme is that the maps rarely present terrain, simply connectivity. Early maps made to promote new lines often featured indications as to what resources (mineral or agricultural) were produced in the areas through which the railway passed. Occasionally there were innovations in presentation, such as using line width to encode freight volumes. In the 20th century novel pictorial formats appeared – advertising for leisurely rail travel.

In Britain railways were not centrally planned but there was oversight via parliamentary act – other countries went for centrally planned systems. Initially many railways were designed to link the production of materials with ports. Railways powered the Industrial Revolution, enabling heavy raw materials to be transported at low cost, and the timely distribution of goods produced. Railways drove the expansion of cities allowing goods, raw materials and people to be brought in daily over significant distances. In Britain rail freight increased more than 10-fold between1850 and 1912. Night travel become more important with signalling improvements.

As the railways grew globally Britain was central in terms of technical know how but also in terms of financing. In different countries the rise of the railways was driven by different commodities – in Uruguay it was beef, in Chile nitrate fertiliser and again linking material production to ports was central.

Prior to the rise of air travel and to a lesser extent car travel, the railways were also associated with luxury enabling pastimes like skiing. I was surprised to learn that the Orient Express service was a locomotive with just three carriages.

In most countries there was a diversity of competing rail companies as the railway systems grew. During the early 20th century there was a tendency for these to merge, many turning out to be uneconomic despite the promises of their developers. This accelerated later in the century as railways declined due to competition from road and air travel.

War features in two chapters, the railways have been central to war for a long time – for troop mobilisation and also to move supplies. During the American Civil War the Union rail network was far more developed than that of the Confederacy which helped them to victory. They are critical even now in Ukraine, for example. In addition to existing railway infrastructure specialised railways were built to support fighting in the trenches during the First World War.

Railways suffered in the post-war periods, typically they had been degraded by attacks and lack of investment during war and then after the war investment was hard to come by. In Britain the 1926 General Strike took a lot of freight off the railways, never to return. Road offers access at all points on a road for low or zero cost. Road vehicles were much cheaper and required limited training. After the Second World War air travel started to take passengers from rail, particularly in Australia, the US and Canada.

In response railways switched to diesel and electric drive reducing costs somewhat but there were widespread managed decline projects such as that of Beeching in the UK. I was surprised to learn that, despite this, American rail freight is quite successful and where they exist passenger services are not doing badly.

There are still grand new rail projects under way such as in Spain, for example, where a high speed rail system is seen as a counter to regional separatist movements. In Asia China’s belt and rail projects are looking to span the continent (despite shipping freight being cheaper). There is a project linking the Baltic states whose existing rail systems focussed on Moscow rather than each other. Delhi is expanding its suburban rail system. In the England HS2 is much reduced largely because it is costing £85 million per kilometre rather than the £13 million per kilometre typical in continental Europe a disparity arising from the large number of tunnels and viaducts built to mitigate local opposition. The COVID pandemic has also led to a 10% reduction in passenger traffic in the UK changing the economics of new railways.

The final chapter of A History of Railways is on various fictional maps and games based on the railways including a map of Sodor, Thomas the Tank Engine’s home island.

This is a beautiful book, the scope is very wide and thus a bit shallow but it provides an interesting overview of the history of railways through vignettes rather than a sweeping narrative.

Book review: Horses by Ludovic Orlando

My next review is of Horses: A 4,000-year genetic journey across the world by Ludovic Orlando (translated by Teresa Lavender Fagan).

It is a product of the work that the author did as the leader of a team of scientists and archaeologists on the evolution of the domesticated horse. The core of this work was to sample horse remains over a wide span of time for DNA to identify where horses were domesticated and how they evolved over time. The book is scattered with vignettes of the scientists and archaeologists with whom he collaborated.

There are eleven thematic chapters, covering the origin of the domesticated horse, the origins of horses in different parts of the world, mules, and horses in different periods of time.

It is worth remembering that a little over 100 years ago horses were economically critical, an outbreak of equine flu had a huge impact on the US economy in 1872/3 since much transport of goods and people was by horse. Indeed the severity of the Boston fire is attributed to the inability to move water pumps because of a lack of horses. Globally the number of horses has declined to around 60 million since the end of the 19th century when it was probably around 75 million but against the background of a human population that has tripled in that time.

The genetic work shows that the origin of the domestic horse is relatively recent – dating to 4200 years ago in the Volga-Don valley bordering the Caspian Sea north of the Caucasus – very close to the part of Ukraine that Russia has recently invaded. All modern horses are descended from this domestication with the exception of the wild Przewalski’s horse which are descended from an abortive earlier domestication in the Botai culture of Northern Kazakhstan. Here the horse had been domesticated a little earlier , approximately 5000 years ago, as evidenced by archaeological remains, but no trace of these horses is found in modern horses (aside from the Przewalski’s horse). Prior to the genetic work the location of the domestication of the horse was uncertain, options covered central Europe and Asia, as well as the Iberian peninsula. It was believed that Przewalski’s horse represented a truly wild horse. Orlando covers pre-domestication horses in a separate chapter but does not go into the textbook evolution of the horse from eohippus.

The domestication of the horse relatively recent compared to other animals. Genetically domesticated horses have two key differences from their wild ancestors, they are more docile and have stronger backs.

Once domesticated the horse spread rapidly across Eurasia, there is a chapter here on whether the Indo-European language group spread simultaneously with the horse but the evidence is that agriculture and language spread before the horse was domesticated but that there was an acceleration around the time of its domestication. Orlando suggests that the key feature of the horse was its ability to carry loads, and that drought in the cradle of its origin drove the migration. It had previously been proposed that the horse had spread via its use in raiding and war-fighting.

Genetics are central to the whole book but don’t really get a consolidated explanation anywhere, I suppose because the details are quite technical and for the reader the key thing is the outcome – for example measuring relatedness and identifying the function of genes which have been selected by breeding. I was curious to learn of the ambling gait for horses, and its origin in a single gene, DMRT3. This is found is specific breeds such as the Icelandic Horse, Peruvian Paso and the Tennessee walking horse. I found the text descriptions of gaits confusing but there are plenty of videos online illustrating the ambling gait, it looks unusually smooth at faster paces.

As soon as humans start domesticating horses the population of horses starts to rise dramatically, human breeders break the rules of the equine social order which greatly increases the breeding capacity. The control breeders exert is even more marked nowadays in the breeding of racehorses. They all have the same notional birthday (1st January in the northern hemisphere) which means that there is a benefit to arranging the birth of foals as close after this date as possible since horses are raced very young and classed by age.

I found the chapter on modern racehorses a bit depressing, the death and injury rates for racehorses particularly in the US is high. Furthermore, genetic defects are persisted deliberately because they confer an advantage in racing the young horse.

There is a chapter on mules, once highly regarded and prestigious both for their “hybrid” vigour and also and their relative scarcity – mules are infertile so they can only be bred directly from donkeys and horses. They were particularly popular with the Romans for use in carrying goods. Also mentioned is the kunga a donkey-onager cross highly valued by the ancient Egyptians.

The chapters on different times and places focus on what we might be able to say about the characteristics of horses from that time or place, so we learn that Medieval war horses were surprisingly small, and that paler horses declined in numbers after the 5th century. The exception to this is the horse in America where the question of whether any of the horses in US have an ancestry outside that originating in Europe – the answer is that they don’t although Orlando talks about their being more work to do in this area.

The book finishes with a chapter on cloning. I was surprised to discover that Argentina seems to have taken the lead on this, cloning polo horses – it has been rather more successful than I expected.

In the epilogue Orlando talks about learning to ride at the age of 42, after he had done the majority of the work in this book!