Tag: Roman

Book review: Domination by Alice Roberts

My next review is of Domination by Alice Roberts, subtitled “The Fall of the Roman Empire and the Rise of Christianity”.

The book is divided into five parts (Land of Saints, The End of Empire, The Heart of Empire, The Business of Empire and Ruler of All) each divided into around ten sections apart from the final part which is a summary and rather shorter.

I must admit to having been a bit cautious about buying this book since Professor Alice Roberts is a relatively high profile humanist so perhaps not sympathetic to the Christian church. On reflection I realised that this was probably an ideal person to write a history of the rise of the Christian church.

Roberts is generally known for writing on anatomy and archaeology. This book is much more historical in character, relying more on written records than archaeology. As a result I think she spends more time being explicit about how we read historical records than might otherwise be the case.

Domination starts in Llantwit Major, in South Wales, with the 6th century saint, Illtud. In a way this is starting at the end, the Roman Empire has fallen but in its place we find a Christian church that in this case is spanning South Wales, Devon and Cornwall and crossing into Brittany. These links were close, Welsh Cornish and Breton were mutually intelligible up until the 11th century there are even provinces in Brittany whose names are similar to Devon and Cornwall.

Roberts writes here about the reliability of written sources from this time. In the early church there was a proliferation of saints, the Pope had no part in sanctifying them until the 12th century. Often saints were promoted in later years with “Live of [your saint here] ” documents, written by members of the church some time later (possibly centuries) with a view to promoting the interests of those places and churches attached to the saint – as such they can’t be considered literal truth. This isn’t to say meaning can’t be extracted from them, we can favour documents written closer to contemporaneously, we can cross-reference between “lives of”, and we can pay attention to what themes emerge and what was seen as desirable in a saint.

Roberts next covers the lead up to the post-Roman period, the transition from a Roman Empire with Christianity as its official religion in 380AD to what came after. The focus here is on buildings although much of the section revolves around the letters of Sidonius Apollinaris, a senior Roman administrator and then bishop who lived from c. 430AD-490AD. Apollinaris lived in what is now France where the Empire ended around 480AD with the invasion of the Franks. Roberts comments that there is more written evidence from this period originating in Gaul than from Britain where there is virtually nothing.

Apollinaris’s letters show how the villa culture of the Roman Empire was active until very late in the Empire. Roberts suggests that Roman villas in Britain did not immediately fall into dis-repair when the Romans formally left: we see the archaeological remains of those villas out in the countryside which fell into ruin but those that went on to become villages are less obvious – the originally buildings having disappeared over the intervening 1500 years. Villas were often places of burial which became cemeteries which became churches. The Roman basicila, a large, aisled administrative building morphed very naturally into early Christian churches.

Christianity rose to dominance in the Roman Empire during the 4th century, becoming the official religion in 380 AD with the Edict of Thessalonica by Theodosius I. Roberts talks much more about Constantine who instituted the Council of Nicaea in 325AD to decide on the fundamentals of what was faith and what was heresy. She talks about this as an exercise in branding and marketing, and a type of culture war. Culture war is a recurring theme through the book, mainly in terms of defining what faith meant in the Christian Church. Constantine was looking for unity in the church to align with his leadership of a newly unified Roman Empire. Constantine had recently got rid of the other members of the tetrarchy ruling the Roman Empire. Later ecclesiastical historians would pitch Constantine as instrumental in making the Christian church the official religion of the Empire through his faith.

Roberts focus then moves to the people that made up the Christian church in the Roman Empire and how its functions grew. Middle-class professionals were moving to the Christian church because it represented a degree of stability in an increasingly uncertain world. We saw earlier how Apollinaris, a senior Roman administrator, became a bishop – this was not an uncommon journey. Many of the early saints were from the Roman elite. Over the years the Christian church became a vast conglomerate of welfare, health, legal, agribusiness, shipping and education with a thin veil of religion cast over it, built with the assistance of the Roman state.

The final section, Ruler of all, is rather shorter and acts as a summary although in addition Roberts draws parallels in this section between the imperial purple and gold of the Roman Emperors and the vestments of bishops. Also in this section is a discussion of how Christianity came to dominate: other cults in the Roman Empire were more permissive of worshipping multiple gods – Christianity was not.

I enjoyed this book, it answers natural questions about the fall of the Roman Empire and the rise of Christianity, it’s readable and provides some good insight into historical methodology. I was interested to understand how this book was received, some brief Googling suggests that the main criticism is that it is “too cynical” – rather than attacking its scholarship.

Book review: Hadrian’s Wall by David J. Breeze and Brian Dobson

This review is of Hadrian’s Wall by David J. Breeze and Brian Dobson. Reading this book was prompted by visiting Birdoswald Roman Fort, on Hadrian’s Wall, during a recent holiday to the Lake District. I have also read more widely about the Romans in Britain.

Hadrian’s Wall is divided into seven chapters titled The Concept of a Frontier, The Building of Hadrian’s Wall, The Antonine Wall, The Two Walls, The Army of the Wall, Life on the wall and The Third and Four Centuries.

There is a short conclusion chapter and extensive appendices covering Roman Emperors and Governors of Britain, The regiments of Hadrian’s Wall, The Gods Worshipped on the Wall, The Roman Names of the Forts on Hadrians Wall and The Evidence on the Ground.

Emperor Hadrian’s plan to build a wall at a boundary was a novelty in the Roman Empire, to that point the Roman army had acted on the implicit assumption that the boundary was the end of the land. They fought battles with mobile units with forts to provide over-winter accommodation for the following year’s fighting. Hadrian made boundaries in both Britain and Germany. They were not strictly fortification, they served to control access in and out of Roman control rather than anticipating pitched battles on the line of the wall.

Perhaps disappointingly for the British, the Roman Emperors tended to stage military actions for their own advancement, Britain sometimes provided a useful arena but more often Roman Emperors were looking to the Middle East. The Emperor Hadrian (117-138AD) had pulled back troops from Britain to fight elsewhere and planned the Wall to define the Roman area of interest in Britain.

Construction of the Wall proper started around 122AD. It was built over a relatively short period, perhaps 3 or 4 years. The Wall followed on from the older Stanegate Roman road which followed roughly the same line but a little further south. The wall itself is relatively wide, 3 metres, certainly wide enough for patrolling but not for fighting. It was built to a clear masterplan with regularly spaced milecastles (small forts), turrets and gates. A series of larger forts were added to the Wall include Birdosvald, Chesters and Vindolanda. The system of forts extends beyond the wall at the Cumbria end, down to Maryport and the is some evidence for a few forts on the North Sea coast. Breeze and Dobson include much minutiae of the construction of the wall and forts, trying to identify which parts were built by which of the several military units. The plan changed during the construction of the wall with the width reducing part way through. A “vallum”, a bank and ditch earthwork, was added south of the Wall a few years after initial construction in around 130AD.

Work on Hadrian’s wall stopped immediately on the death of Hadrian in 138AD, he was succeeded by Antonius Pius, his adopted son, who started work on his own Wall, the Antonine Wall. Although there is no evidence it seems likely that the construction was a question of military prestige, most likely backed by local generals bored of simply manning a wall. The Antonine Wall was of turf on a stone base, similarly forts had turf ramparts although might contain, it runs between the Forth and Clyde estuaries and is approximately half the length of Hadrian’s Wall. Hadrian’s Wall was largely abandoned when the Antonine Wall was built.

There’s very little written evidence for what was going on in Britain in the mid to late 2nd century. Hadrian’s Wall was reoccupied in 158AD and the Antonine Wall abandoned by the mid 160s. It seems there was some sort of uprising in southern Scotland in the last two decades of the second century.

There is quite a lot known of the structure and career paths in the Roman army, along with the standards for building forts. In the early years these don’t seem to have been greatly adapted for Northern Britain – they contain verandas to protect from the sun! Most notably Hadrian’s Wall was largely manned by auxiliary units largely drawn from the local population. Members of these units signed up for 25 years of service, with 60% surviving the full term. Auxiliary unit members were rewarded with citizenship at the end of their term. Breeze and Dobson note that promotion was often down to personal recommendations and client/patron relationships. We also know a fair amount about life on the Wall from archaeology, including the famous Vindalonda written tablets. Auxiliary soldiers may well have had wives and children who lived outside the walls of the fort or perhaps even inside in the later period of the Roman occupation.

The early third century was tumultuous for the Roman Empire in the early third century although Britain was largely outside of this, over the years. Later in the century there was fighting with the Picts. The Romans finally left Britain in 411AD, or at least that’s when they stopped paying their soldiers in Britain. It is likely individuals remained in place in the area around the wall after this date. Their departure was due problems closer to home in Rome, rather than being militarily pushed out.

It is difficult to recommend this book to the general reader. It seems more directed to the professional by including a lot of very detailed information on, for example, the proportions of forts whilst scarcely touching, for example, on where troop disposition information comes from. There are no scene building asides referencing the researchers the authors have met which is perhaps unsurprising since that was not the style for books like this when it was initially published in 1974, this edition is from 1999.

Book review: Ancient Rome Infographics by Nicolas Guillerat, John Scheid and Milan Melocco

There’s no real alternative to a good browse around a bookshop, this book Ancient Rome Infographics by Nicolas Guillerat, John Scheid and Milan Melocco is the result of just such browsing. I’ve been interested in the history of Britain, and the important part the Romans played in it for a while so this was a welcome find. I’m interested in data visualisation, so it’s fair to say this is the sort of exercise I would undertake given data on the Roman Empire!

The authors emphasise several times that the underlying data for these infographics is sometimes uncertain and that there is pretty much no data prior to the fourth century BCE so this period is ignored. They provide an extensive bibliography although it is not referenced at an individual infographic level.

The book is divided into three parts:

  1. The Lands and People of the Empire
  2. Government, worship and social needs
  3. Rome’s military might

The infographics generally span a double page spread, and usually include explanatory text. I’m finding writing a review a bit challenging without reproducing the infographics, the publisher Thames & Hudson have some examples on their product page.

From the first section I liked the visualisation showing the physical extent of the Roman Empire and its growth in both population and area over time. I was surprised to learn that the Iberian peninsula contained a large chunk of the Roman population (5,000,000) compared to 7,000,000 in Italy. The population of Egypt was also significant (4,500,000) although it was absorbed rather later, in 27 BCE. The Roman Empire continued to expand until 150CE.

This section includes quite a lot of detailed information on Rome particularly in terms of the types of buildings in the city, and how the footprint of the city evolved over time. I assume that the Roman remains in Rome have been subject to a huge amount of study hence the large quantity of data. Rome grew to a population of 1.75 million in the 3rd century CE declining to 500,000 in the mid 5th century CE.

Also included are rather complex diagrams of the social and legal classes in Roman society. I must admit I found this less interesting. The authors mention several times that one of the strengths of the Roman Empire was that citizens from all the states across the Empire became fully fledged Roman citizens, as well as citizens of their local state. The social structure was very oriented around voting men, with the paterfamilias – the senior man in a household – essentially holding all of the rights the state bestowed which they distributed as they saw fit to their household. The paterfamilias might also have a patron-client relationship with others outside the household, I suspect this is one of many topics which warrants a whole book to elucidate.

The second section continues with the delineation of roles in society with the focus on the political and government. My favourite part here was the chronology of emperors which also introduced the term damnatio memoriae which is an attempt to expunge an emperor from the historical record. The term, although Latin, was coined in the 17th century. Some emperors had quite long reigns but at other times there were flurries of emperors, or at least those that proclaimed themselves so. This is where the infographic presentation falls down a bit – subtleties are lost because they cannot be presented cleanly. From towards the end of the third century CE there are Eastern and Western empires each with their own emperor and for a brief period there was the “Tetrarchy” – a system of two senior and two junior emperors.

Religion gets a few pages, Romans had a system of public and private “cults” – a city would follow a public cult with its ceremonies and rituals but individuals could also follow their own cult with a shrine and ritual in their home. Later the Christian faith was to spread through the Empire encompassing over half of the population by 350CE.

Also in this chapter is data on the production of grain, and the cost of living. For quite some period the residents of Rome had a “grain dole”, or annona which gave an allocation of grain to selected citizens of Rome (adult male citizens). The cost of living data is so interesting I’m tempted to do my own visualisations! For example 1 rabbit cost 32 as (a small Roman coin) but a pound of wild boar meet was only 8 as. 8 as would also buy you a prostitute but a bath was only 0.25 as. Slaves started at 800 as but went up to nearly 100,000 as for “1 very attractive slave”. A skilled worker could earn 12 as per day, a legionary (a junior rank) 10 as / day, a centurion 165 as / day and a senator 5480 as / day.

The final chapter covers war, I was a bit surprised to learn that the Roman army and navy were not that great but they made good use of local fighters and were good at simply being present. There are descriptions, and infographics of Roman marching orders, camp construction processes and the the evolving equipment of a Roman soldier. I sometimes wonder how accurately such prescriptions were followed, I assume there is at least one documentary source for these processes but how closely were they followed in the field?

I liked the visualisation showing movements of one Roman legionary through his career around Armenia and Eastern Europe. The Social Wars, Punic Wars, conquering Gaul and Spartacus have their own sections in this chapter. I’m assuming these are the most important of the Roman wars.

Overall I enjoyed this book, although I was sometimes frustrated by the complexity of the infographics. It works well as a taster for further investigation.

Book review: Roads in Roman Britain by Hugh Davies

My next review is of Roads in Roman Britain by Hugh Davies. Davies was a road engineer, and the study of Roman roads is a retirement project for him, which amused me since I am currently contemplating retirement. I don’t mean this pejoratively – I think in Roads he did a great job bringing together his expertise and the existing academic work in the area, as well as his own original research. He gained a PhD in 2001 from Reading University. In addition he has compiled a database of Roman road characteristics which is exactly my sort of thing.

The book starts with some basic definitions of what a road is and how it is structured. Davies focusses on the function of the road as a transport mechanism rather than as a boundary indicator, a navigation system or an expression of Roman power – uses I hadn’t really considered. As a structure a road has a route and a cross-section. I liked the quote from John London McAdam which basically said the function of the road cross-section was to stop the running surface becoming unusable as a result of water coming from above or below!

There is very limited primary documentary evidence for the Roman roads of Britain, there is the Antonine Iternary, tables of routes across the Roman empire which includes some routes in Britain and the Peutiger Tables, a sort of pseudo-map of roads across the Roman Empire of which Britain is only covered in a small fragment showing the far south east of the country.

This leaves us with archaeology, fortunately Roman roads in Britain have been excavated for many years. Less fortunately dating evidence is sparse in roads. Some roads identified as Roman may well date to medieval or even the 17th century when the turnpike roads were the first to match the quality of construction of Roman roads. It’s worth noting that none of the names used for Roman roads (Watling Street, Ermine Street, the Foss Way etc) are original – they are labels dating to the medieval period at earliest. It is not clear if Romans used any sort of naming for roads.

Archaeological practices have improved over the years, it is only really in the last quarter of the 20th century that it was appreciated that Roman roads are structures that were repaired and reconstructed over centuries.

I think the most interesting idea in this book Davis’s proposal for a reason for the straightness of Roman roads. He argues, unlike others, that the Roman’s must have made some sort of map before laying out roads and that the likelihood was that this was some large scale object possibly inscribed onto a floor. Under these circumstances straight road segments are the easiest to transmit to “the field”. It is easy to say “go to this point, build a straight road in this direction until you have gone this distance”, imagine trying to describe a more complex route accurately.

One of the recurring themes of the book is as to whether the Romans built roads to a strict pattern in terms of construction details and width. Justinian codified road classifications in the 6th century AD; an iter is pedestrian only, actus will allow a beast of burden, via will allow a cart however no numerical widths were defined. The Twelve Tables from fifth century BC says a straight section of road must be 8 pedes (Roman feet) wide on the straight an 16 on corners. However, on the ground road widths follow quite a broad distribution with a peak around 20 pedes (which is about six metres). This is wide enough for two-way cart traffic.

Based on the road surface (crushed stone/gravel) and the maximum gradients Davies suggests that Roman roads were designed for heavy carts moving at walking pace rather than fast passenger carriages. I was interested to learn the optimum gradients for carts are based on the rolling resistance of the surface balancing gravity (which becomes larger for steeper slopes). This is to avoid runaway carts since braking technology at the time was poor.

In the past historians have tended to the view that the Romans worked in a very regimented fashion. Davies comes down on the side of a more flexible approach determined by local factors. This is complicated in the archaeological record by repair and reconstruction activities, in some places there is evidence for 9 or 10 cycles of repair/reconstruction – sometimes this is as an addition on top of an older road but sometimes it is a widening of the route.

Davies observes that there is a difference in construction methods between the north and west of the country and the south and east with the north and west making greater use of stone. He attributes this to much more significant military use in the north and west, and better availability of suitable stone.

There is a chapter on Roman town plans which looked like it could be a whole separate book. Roman towns are typically built on a grid sometimes this grid is based around a Roman road alignment – suggesting road predates town and sometimes the road deviates to adapt to the town grid, suggesting town predates road.

Davies covers fairly briefly the development of the network over time, in terms of the military function of roads. The Royal Engineers estimated that the initial road from a Kent invasion landing point to London would have taken 1000 men about 15 weeks, a full version would take 3400 men about 3 years. The Roman road system was not fully developed until into the 2nd century AD – some 60 or so years after the invasion. London was not the transport centre of Britain at the beginning of the Roman occupation but became so over time.

This book is somewhat specialist, I enjoyed it because I’m interested in civil engineering and Roman history. It is short and readable, and I think provides a unique perspective.

Book review: Roman Britain – A New History by Guy de la Bédoyère

Following on from my previous review of Echolands by Duncan MacKay on Boudica’s revolt against the Roman occupiers of Britain, this review is of Roman Britain: A New History by Guy de la Bédoyère. Roman Britain has a much wider scope than Echolands covering the whole period of Roman influence in Britain from Caesar’s abortive invasions in 55 and 54BC through to the period after the Roman’s left Britain in 410AD. This is a larger format book with illustrations and photographs on virtually every page.

The book starts with three chapters on the timeline of Roman Britain covering the pre-invasion period, the extended conquest and the later period. Eight chapters follow on different themes: governing Britain, military installations, towns in Roman Britain, industry, commerce and production, the countryside and villas, people and places of roman Britain, religion in Roman Britain and the aftermath.

Britain was know to the Greeks as far back as the 4th century BC, and there was trade in tin from Britain from that time. By the middle of the 2nd century BC ornate burials were being found in Britain containing imported goods, and coinage was starting to be found. Hengistbury Head, where my father lived in his retirement, was an important trade port in this period. This tells us that Britain was not unknown to the outside world when Caesar made his invasion attempts in 55BC and 54BC. These were unsuccessful in the immediate sense but over the intervening years to the invasion proper in 43AD there was a gradual Romanisation of the upper echelons of British society, and increased trade.

Both Caesar’s abortive invasion, and Claudius’s successful invasion in 43AD were driven by politics in Rome, military success were a credit to an Emperor. British politics may well have played a part: Cunobelinus, king of a large chunk of Britain, died in 43AD and the resulting uncertainty over succession was a good opportunity to invade. Claudius’s invasion succeeded because the Roman army were a very efficient, well-equipped military force and their opposition was divided with some on the British side likely supporting the Romans.

The Romans spread to a line linking Lincoln and Exeter by 47AD, and by the end of the 1st century they had reached the limits of Wales and the far North of Scotland. Over the next 50 years there was some consolidation but by 150AD the Roman’s had reached the geographic limit of their occupation of Britain. It seems that the South-East of Britain became fairly well Romanised with villas and towns in the Roman style. North and West of the 47AD frontier life seemed to continue more in the manner of the Iron Age but for the addition of Roman garrisons and forts with related trade and industries.

Most of what we know of Roman life in Britain is based on the inscriptions left by the military, on tombstones and dedications of building works. There are limited number of wooden writing tablets, discovered at Vindolanda by Hadrian’s Wall and in London, which provide a fascinating insight into daily life, trade and interpersonal relationships. The early period of the occupation is discussed in Tacitus’s writings, as well as some other fragments.

We get a very small sample of daily life from from archaeology, only about 0.01% of all deaths are represented in burials and, assuming villas had 40 occupants each, homes for only about 0.01% are known.

Much of the rest of our understanding seems to come from recognising that Britain was being run like any other Roman province and extrapolating across archaeological and historical writings from all over the empire. Roman’s had firm ideas about which people could hold which positions (qualified by property), and Roman towns had a specific set of amenities according to their official type. Britain was seen as a troublesome province and had quite senior governors who typically only had a short tenure – some went on to become Emperor.

The Roman’s seemed to have respected the British as traders, seeing them as taking on Roman ways in this regard. Agriculture was important, and there is a lot of evidence of lead production – unlike iron, lead tends to survive quite well. Coinage was only minted in Britain from the late third century – it would not be used so heavily until the 17th.

There is limited evidence for the health and ethnicity of the Roman Britons, they seem to have increased dental issues. There was certainly the idea of branded medications, particularly for eye conditions. It isn’t clear whether there was a patent system. It is certain that Roman soldiers came from around the Empire but identifying them is hard since typically they Romanised their names.

Most of the writing we find the Roman period relates to religion (shrines, tombstones, altars). For a large part of the Roman period people worshipped hybrid Gods – amalgams of Roman Gods with local pagan deities or even from elsewhere in the Roman empire. Later the Christian church became established – we have written evidence of a church hierarchy from 314AD.

From the beginning of the third century AD the Roman empire was beginning to split up. Rome finally withdrew support for the military occupation of Britain in 410AD. This had an immediate economic impact because there was no longer new coinage coming into the country, or military salaries to spend. Physically Roman buildings decayed over a period of 150 years or so with the now non-Roman occupants no longer having the will or skill to repair them. We can mark the complete end of practical Roman influence with the invasion of the Anglo-Saxons in 577AD although we see the marks of the Roman occupation even now in our landscape and language.

Roman Britain finishes with a chronology and a guide to visiting Roman sites in Britain, I feel in this section insufficient attention is paid to my home town of Chester!

This is a beautiful book, and rather readable.